Probably the main reason most people used to buy a new car was because it wasn’t worth keeping their old car. Maybe it needed a new transmission or some other major repair and it didn’t make sense to put a lot of money into an old car. That dynamic has reversed. It now makes a lot of sense to put money into an old car in order to avoid spending a fortune on a new one.
$52,380 being the fortune it takes to buy the average new vehicle – not taking into account the cost of insuring it as well as all the taxes associated with owning it. (In states that levy property taxes on vehicles, which are based on “book value,” the hit can easily be $1,000 annually. For years – until the vehicle depreciates enough to cause the “book value” – and so, the tax – to be less than that.)
This sum – plus interest on the loan – puts spending $5,000 on a new transmission that will keep your old car going for another five years, probably, into perspective. Especially since it’s likely you’ll get more than another five years out of the car. But let’s say five, just for the sale of this discussion, before some other big thing goes wrong. That $5k you spent to get a new transmission put into it works out to $1,000 for each of those five years – or about $85 per month. As opposed to close to $800 per month – for the next six years – to pay off that $52,380 new car (not counting the tens of thousands in depreciation losses).
It’s more than just this, though.
Awareness is percolating that new cars will cost much more to repair when they get old. If they are even fixable. Here’s a particularly teeth-aching case in point: Nissan dealers do not carry certain critical parts (such as seals) for the Aisin automatic transmission used in some 2016-2020 Titan XD models; the fix is to replace the transmission – which typically runs $12,000-$17,000.
What do you suppose those fancy-looking gigantic LCD screens used in all new cars will cost to replace when they inevitably glitch? Keep in mind that many important secondary systems – such as the climate controls – are controlled via tap/swipe through the screen, so if the screen goes so do those functions. A reader who owns a late-model car with a big touchscreen told me she asked the dealer what it would cost to replace. The answer – interestingly – was $5,000. This is right now. What will it cost five years from now.
Will a replacement screen even be available then?
I have several professional mechanic friends and they all tell me that cars made since about 2020 are basically throw-away cars once the new car warranty expires because they are not worth fixing. Unlike the vehicles made before then, which often are. Especially the older ones made during the Golden Age of modern vehicles, which was – roughly – the late ’90s through about 2010. These cars are worth fixing because they usually can be fixed, first of all. Meaning, they are repairable. New cars are designed not to be. The plastic hardens and cracks and you replace the part – assuming it’s available. There’s so much built-in complexity, too, that even professional mechanics with the proper training and equipment often have trouble figuring out and fixing whatever it is that’s gone wrong. 
Older vehicles – especially the ones that do not have LCD screens, drive-by-wire anything or body control modules but nevertheless still have modern, fuel-injected engines and overdrive transmissions that make them start, run and drive just as well as any brand-new car (and often, more reliably) are only “old” in terms of years. They are not like the functionally old cars made before the advent of electronically fuel-injected engines and overdrive transmissions. No such cars have been made since the late 1980s. Put another way, everything made since then is modern. Nothing made since then runs or drives like an old car.
I drive a 25 year-old truck. It is old enough to qualify for Antique Vehicle plates, but it is a very different kind of vehicle than my actually antique 1976 Trans-Am, which has a carbureted engine and a non-overdrive transmission. I love the TA in part because it is an old car – not just in terms of its age but mainly because it is nothing like a modern car. My old truck, on the other hand, is just as easy to start and runs and drives as well (or even better) than the brand-new cars I test drive and write about.
True, it does not have electronic climate control or a big LCD touchscreen or any “advanced driver assistance technology.” But that is exactly why it’s superior (as I see it) to anything new and well worth putting $5k into, too.
. . .
If you like what you’ve found here please consider supporting EPautos.
We depend on you to keep the wheels turning!
Our donate button is here.
If you prefer not to use PayPal, our mailing address is: EPautos 721 Hummingbird Lane SE Copper Hill, VA 24079









