Latest Reader Qs (6/24/2017)

2
1419
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Here are the latest reader Qs along with my answers:

Gary asks:

Can you recommend a reliable crossover in the $20,000 or less range? My daughter will be doing a lot of driving for her job and needs a reliable vehicle that gets pretty good gas mileage. She is interested in the Subaru Outback and the Honda Crosstour. I’m not sold on the Subaru. Looks like a lot of complaints about the engines. I saw your post in the ask Peter section where a reader asked about a good vehicle in a given price range and one of the vehicles you recommended was the Lexus RX. Still a thumbs up? Any advice you can offer would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

Hi Gary!

Both the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 are top-drawer choices in my book. They have excellent track records for reliability and durability; neither has overly complex equipment (e.g., neither comes with a turbocharged engine and both have straightforward transmissions; no over-the-top eight/ten speeds or dual-clutch boxes). While a little boring, both of these are very versatile, useful, fuel-efficient driving appliances. If your daughter is young/college-age, either of them would be ideal as they have lots of room for carrying stuff around and don’t generally need much in the way of maintenance. 

New, these cost just over $24k to start but you could probably find a 2-3 year old one with say 30,000 or so miles on it for less than your $20k budget.

The Outback is priced just slightly higher (new) and its chief draw vs. the RAV4 and CR-V is that it comes standard with AWD (the Honda and Toyota offer it at extra cost but come standard with FWD).

AWD can be nice to have if you live in an area that tends to get a lot of snow in winter – but if not, your daughter would probably be fine with FWD and the vehicle will cost less to buy and also get better mileage (AWD crossovers are heavier, etc.). FWD crossovers are actually pretty good in snow; in part because they pull themselves along rather than push themselves along. The weight of the engine/transmission over the drive wheels helps traction, too. And both have pretty decent ground clearance, which is another big help in snow. With good winter tires, in anything short of a blizzard, either of these do surprisingly well in winter driving conditions.  

Subarus are generally good/reliable cars – and the AWD (and more ground clearance) makes them very capable in bad weather – but you will pay more for one and when shopping for a used one, there is the additional element of risk with regard to the AWD system as well as the more complex flat-four engine. Also – an important thing – older Subarus are terrible gas pigs vs. other cars in their class. The new ones (which have CVT automatics) are better, but your budget puts them out of reach.

The Lexus RX is a great vehicle but it is also a luxury vehicle – and priced accordingly. New, these cost $43k to start. To find a used one within your budget, you’d be looking at well-used examples with very high miles and likely high maintenance/repair costs. This is also a larger (mid-sized, almost full-sized) vehicle. The other three are in the medium-compact class (there is a lot of overlap nowadays).

Hope this was helpful!

-Eric

Mike asks:

I get the message,”Safari Can’t Connect To Server. “This happens only when I try to post a comment. I can read site content just fine. Used to be able to post just fine too, up till 2-3 months ago.
What happened? Any fix?
Hi Mike! 
I wish I knew. 
Cars, I know. Computers – code – might as well be Sanskrit. I will ask my computer guy, though. I know many people are having similar issues…
Thanks for the heads up!
-Eric

If you like what you’ve found here, please consider supporting EPautos. (Latest radio guest appearance can be heard here.)

We depend on you to keep the wheels turning!

Our donate button is here.

 If you prefer not to use PayPal, our mailing address is:

EPautos
721 Hummingbird Lane SE
Copper Hill, VA 24079

PS: EPautos stickers are free to those who send in $20 or more to support the site. 

 

 

Share Button

2 COMMENTS

  1. Dear Eric, after reading about this new bill submitted to Congress by Chuck “the fuck” Grassley, Pelosi, Charles(fuck the little guy)Cornyn and Whitehouse(S. 1241) in which all monies including cash, bit coin, barter and precious metal will be accounted for and the whereabouts of such monies stated on record by every person….for the ultimate control of everyone in the U.S. I have a question of my own.

    What SUV or enclosed vehicle do you recommend to haul a mini-gun along with the Ton of ammo needed?

    Also, would you recommend a collapsible stock MP 4 or an IWI Tavor with a 16.5″ barrel for the “shotgun” rider? And what would be an alternative for the driver to a Mac? Ah, I just answered my own question and it’s a Tavor for both.

  2. I completely agree with your $20k crossover feedback to Gary. I will also point out that the Honda Crosstour is a very bad choice for his daughter’s intended purpose. It is expensive and gets very bad gas mileage. A friend of mine was lucky to get 19mpg on the highway. It is more cramped inside than the Honda CR-V (which has much more cargo room, too), costs more, and is more rare, so likely more expensive to repair. That said, they are comfortable and solidly built, but very heavy.

    In addition to the CR-V and RAV4, he may wish to consider the Mazda CX-5. Honda and Toyota both hold their value, so they’ll be harder to find in a late model for $20k. The Mazda is as reliable as those but doesn’t hold its value quite as well and is a fun car to drive and better looking, to boot. It’s possible to find new copies of last year’s model on the lot for under $23k right now. Slightly used ones will be even cheaper. It’s probably the best bargain in the lightly used crossover market right now. They just came out with the all new 2017s this year, so the last generation 2016s are cheap but well sorted out and great all arounders, especially with the 2.5L engine. They even come in manual transmission optionally.

LEAVE A REPLY