“hero” Goes Free… Taxpayers Not So Much

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

The “hero” law enforcer who shot Minnesota driver Philando Castile to death last year was acquitted of all criminal charges but a jury just awarded his family $3 million – the sum to come out of the hides of Minnesota taxpayers.

This is the real “get out of jail free” card.

When “heroes” run amok, they don’t pay. We do.

It is perhaps the ultimate brutality. Taxpayers forced to fund the cost of their own debasement and abuse at the hands of immunized thugs waving badges and guns.

The $3 million settlement will be paid to Philando Castile’s mother Valerie Castile, who is the family’s trustee. The award was announced Monday and comes less than two weeks after “hero” Jeronimo Yanez was acquitted of manslaughter and other charges connected to her son’s death.

Castile, a 32-year-old elementary school cafeteria worker, was shot five times by Yanez during a traffic stop after Castile informed the officer he was armed. Castile had a permit for his gun. The shooting gained widespread attention after Castile’s girlfriend, who was in the car with her then-4-year-old daughter, livestreamed its gruesome aftermath on Facebook.

The acquittal of Yanez, who is Latino, prompted days of protests, including one in St. Paul that shut down Interstate 94 for hours and ended with 18 arrests.

The $2.995 million settlement for Valerie Castile will be paid by the League of Minnesota Cities Insurance Trust, which holds the insurance policy for the city of St. Anthony. The plan for distribution of funds requires approval by a state court, which could take several weeks.

Robert Bennett, who along with attorney Glenda Hatchett is representing Valerie Castile, said a decision was made to move expeditiously rather than have the case drawn out in federal court, a process that would “exacerbate and reopen terrible wounds.” The settlement will also allow the family, the city and community to work toward healing, Bennett said.

“No amount of money could ever replace Philando,” a joint statement from the attorneys and city of St. Anthony said. “With resolution of the claims the family will continue to deal with their loss through the important work of the Philando Castile Relief Foundation.”

Bennett said the foundation’s mission is to provide financial support, grief counseling, scholarships and other help to individuals and families affected by gun violence and police violence.

Bennett said Castile’s girlfriend, Diamond Reynolds, is not part of the settlement. Reynolds has also hired an attorney, but it’s not clear if she is still planning a lawsuit or has any standing for a federal claim. Reynolds’ attorney did not return messages Monday.

Darin Richardson, claims manager with the League of Minnesota Cities, said St. Anthony’s insurance coverage is $3 million per occurrence. If Reynolds were to file and win a claim, the city’s remaining $5,000 in coverage would be paid to her, and St. Anthony would have to cover any additional money awarded.


During his trial, Yanez, 29, testified that Castile ignored his commands not to pull out his gun. The officer said he feared for his life. According to squad-car video that captured the shooting, Castile said: “I’m not pulling it out” before Yanez fired seven rapid shots. Castile’s last words after the shooting were “I wasn’t reaching …”

Reynolds later said Castile was reaching for his wallet.

The squad-car video shows the shooting, but does not show what happened inside the car or what Yanez saw, leaving room for reasonable doubt.

After Yanez’s acquittal, the city of St. Anthony said it was offering Yanez a “voluntary separation agreement” from the police department, and he would no longer be an on-duty “hero.” The department serves the cities of St. Anthony, Lauderdale and Falcon Heights, where the shooting occurred.



Share Button


  1. It would be poetic justice if Valerie Castile devoted some of that money to dogging hero Jeronimo for the rest of his life, making sure he never held a job again. He’s sure to go somewhere else and get hired as a cop again unless he’s exposed everywhere he goes.

  2. I wonder how fast this hero will be hired on somewhere else. I bet it won’t be too long. He will probably have to suffer moving a couple hundred miles, but he will get back into LE somehow (what else can these people do?) even if it’s a mall cop. There will still be hundreds of departments very willing to open their arms to this creep though.

    There should be a database for fired heroes (and other public employees as well). But if you or I set one up, we would get sued for invading these peoples privacy. Too bad we mundanes don’t get the same amount of privacy. It’s not like public agencies would even check it, if you saw those kids in some high school finding out in a five minute google search that their new principal was a fraud. That school either ignored or didn’t look, neither of which is good.

    I wouldn’t be surprised if criminal (and ethical) misconduct is way higher in the public sector vs. the private sector.