NY Heroes Arrest Man for Guitar Playing

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

A man playing guitar in the New York Subway was filmed being forcefully arrested by a police officer last week, despite the fact that public performance in the space is entirely legal. The man raised the ire of the cop when he stood up for his rights and refused to stop playing. The resulting video has gone viral, prompting follow up protests.

30 year old Andrew Kalleen, was performing at the Lorimer Street-Metropolitan Avenue G-train stop in Williamsburg, a popular Brooklyn hangout. The video begins as the police officer falsely states that the Metropolitan Transportation Authority rules require performers to have a permit.

In reality, the MTA does not issue permits. Kalleen hands the officer a digital copy of the MTA rules, which state that playing music is allowed on the subway as long as it does not hamper transit activity.

The exact wording of the rules is as follows:

“The following nontransit uses are permitted by the Authority, provided they do not impede transit activities and they are conducted in accordance with these rules: public speaking; campaigning; leafletting or distribution of written noncommercial materials; activities intended to encourage and facilitate voter registration; artistic performances, including the acceptance of donations.”

The cop reads the rules aloud, verifying that what Kalleen was doing is permitted, and prompting applause from onlookers, but then tells Kalleen “I’m not going to argue with you,” as he stands up for his rights. “I’m asking you to move on,” the cop states “I’m saying no,” Kalleen replies, prompting the officer to threaten him with arrest.

“Get your stuff. You’re leaving…BY FORCE, or you can go out on your own.” the officer tells Kalleen. When he refuses, the cop calls for back up.

Kalleen then begins to play Pink Floyd’s ‘Wish You Were Here,’ as onlookers put money into his guitar case. This prompts the cop to physically stop Kalleen from strumming the guitar, and remove it from him. But he continues to sing, and picks up the guitar once again.

“I’m being oppressed” Kalleen states, as the cop once again attempts to physically remove him from the station.

As Kalleen again cites the MTA rules, the cop shows that he has misunderstood what he read, claiming “it said [guitar playing] is prohibited.”

“There are crack dealers in New York City, and you’re arresting this man for playing guitar!” an onlooker shouts, adding “You don’t have anything better to so there are people breaking laws in the city!”

As Kalleen begins to play Neil Young’s protest anthem ‘Ohio’, the cop again grabs the guitar, slamming it into his face, then cuffs him and hauls him away, prompting onlookers to boo and chant “f*ck the police”.

Kalleen was charged with loitering and spent a night in a police holding cell. However, the arrest was quickly voided when the video went viral. The NYPD issued a statement indicating that the officer involved will not face disciplinary measures, but will be retrained.

Speaking with CBS News, Kalleen said “This time, I decided that I was just going to stand up for my rights and say no… These incidents continue to happen on a daily basis, and we are taught to obey the authorities, so people do. And they leave their spots, and it’s not legal.”


Share Button


  1. It would have been nice to see a bystander intervene. But I’m just glad to see the guitar player himself stand up.

    “…resisting unlawful arrest — while considered a crime, and prosecuted as if it were — is an ancient, venerable, and indispensable right of free people. Under the still-valid Supreme Court precedent John Black Elk v. U.S. (1900), a citizen has a legally recognized right to use lethal force to prevent the consummation of an unlawful arrest, and bystanders likewise have a right (and perhaps a moral duty) to intervene on behalf of the victim.”


  2. Would have been better if the onlookers made a civil arrest of the orificer. Charges being assault and battery, unlawful arrest and harassment.

    I know, I know.. the citizen is often powerless on his own, but with all the witnesses he has a great case, including the video.

    • Der Tag kommt… I hope.

      In this situation, all it would have taken is for one brave soul to take the lead.

      It’s got to happen… or we’re all cooked.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here